Romance novels are my guilty pleasure. But sometimes I wonder what I'd do if what I'm reading actually happened to me in real life. Some of them would give me serious butterflies, but others? It would either creep me out or annoy me to no end.
They can be a bit cringey, overwhelming, and borderline alarming. Here are nine of my favorite romance novel tropes that make me swoon in fiction but roll my eyes in real life.
1. The "Alpha Male" Trope
The domineering, possessive alpha male can be alluring and hot in the books. But in real life? Just no. A man who can't respect my independence and tries to control everything isn't sexy; it's toxic.
Fave Books with Alpha-hole Characters
- Reverie - Shain Rose
- Highball Rush - Lucy Score & Claire Kingsley
- The Price of Scandal - Lucy Score
- The Unwanted Marriage - Catharina Maura
- By a Thread - Lucy Score
- Crossing the Lines - Lucy Score
- Things We Never Got Over - Lucy Score
- The Mistletoe Kisser - Lucy Score
- Mr. Fixer Upper - Lucy Score
- Unraveling Him - Claire Kingsley
- A Photo Finish - Elsie Silver
- The Front Runner - Elsie Silver
2. Insta-love
While the idea of two people instantly recognizing their soulmates is swoon-worthy in novels, solid relationships take time and effort to develop in reality. Give me that slow-burn connection any day. I'd be really scared to be with someone I barely know. I mean, he could be a serial killer, you know?
(Before Sunrise is one of my all time favorite romantic movies, and it's the ultimate and cutest Insta-love trope).
3. Misunderstandings that Last Forever
Dude, just talk to her. Communication is key. I'd be frustrated if a tiny misunderstanding led to a prolonged breakup in real life, like it does in many romance plots.
4. Bad Boy Transformation
I believe a person will change if he wants to, not because someone made him/her. It's lovely when it happens in the book. The unraveling and the reformation of the rake are charming. But I'll have trust issues if someone I know to have a reputation will swear to me I'm different, and I made him change.
Fave Book with Bad Boy Transformation
5. The Persistent Suitor
In novels, it's portrayed as romantic that someone never gives up on their love interest, even if initially rejected. In reality, persistence can easily cross into the territory of not respecting boundaries. It borders on stalking and obsession.
6. Jealousy as a Sign of Love
A little bit of jealousy might be endearing in a story, but in real life, excessive jealousy can be suffocating and problematic. And personally, that is insulting because you don't trust me enough. I would feel like you're limiting me from being friends with or at least talking to people.
Fave Authors Who Write with Neanderthal, Territorial, Jealous Characters:
7. Marrying After a Week
Whirlwind romances in books? Adorable. In real life? It might work for some, but I believe in getting to know someone deeply before making that kind of commitment. It's like Insta-love but on a different level. It's still good to marry your best friend.
8. Fake Dating
I'm a massive fan of this trope in books. That moment when the characters realize and reveal that it's not pretend anymore? Sign me up! Pretending to be a couple for some reason might lead to real feelings in books, but it's a tricky foundation for a genuine relationship in reality.
Fave Fake Dating Books
- Faking Ms. Right - Claire Kingsley
- The Fine Art of Faking It - Lucy Score
- The Front Runner - Elsie Silver
- Glimmers of You - Catherine Cowles
- The Girl With The Make-Believe Husband - Julia Quinn (fake marriage)
9. Grumpy Boss
It centers around a boss who is usually stern, cold, or distant, but through the course of the romance, reveals a more vulnerable and passionate side. There is nothing cute or charming in a boss who seems to enjoy making your work doubly hard. Especially those who get off in humiliating or contradicting you. But yes, I'll read and swoon over it in books. Every. Single. Time.
Fave Grumpy Boss Books
- One Bossy Dare - Nicole Snow
- One Bossy Proposal - Nicole Snow
- One Bossy Date - Nicole Snow
- The Temporary Wife - Catharina Maura
9. Enemies to Lovers
Fave Enemies to Lovers Books
- Stolen Moments Trilogy - Catharina Maura
- Unraveling Him - Claire Kingsley
- Chasing Her Fire - Claire Kingsley
- Falling for My Enemy - Claire Kingsley
- Wild Open Hearts - Kathryn Nolan
- Things We Never Got Over - Lucy Score
- The Mistletoe Kisser - Lucy Score
- The Christmas Fix - Lucy Score
- Off to the Races - Elsie Silver
11 comments
Yeah, there are so many things that are cute in fiction but not so much in actual life.
ReplyDeleteYour reflection on these tropes is spot on. While romance novels provide an escape, it's crucial to remember that real relationships thrive on understanding, open communication, and mutual respect. Thanks for sharing your thoughts – it's a reminder that fiction and reality don't always align!
ReplyDeleteI perfect slow burn connections, too. I love it when you're rooting for them to realise they are perfect for each other!
ReplyDeleteCorinne x
https://skinnedcartree.com
What a fun post! I enjoyed reading about these different tropes and your examples! Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteEnjoy your romance novels ~
ReplyDeleteWishing you good health, laugther and love in your days,
A ShutterBug Explores,
aka (A Creative Harbor)
Enemies to lovers if my favorite trope.
ReplyDeletewww.rsrue.blogspot.com
Misunderstandings can be a real thing in relatioinships and family as well. You're right, just talk to the other person. Good advice. : )
ReplyDelete~Sheri
Romance novels are not my kind of literature, but I agree, especially misunderstandings that never ending are annoying.
ReplyDeleteBefore Sunrise is a favorite of mine. I haven't seen it in a while- and this is reminding me to curl up on the couch and watch it again soon. Much overdue. Thanks for the reminder. :)
ReplyDeleteThis is SO true, they may work in the movies like who does't swoon over Cillian Murphy in Peaky Blinders but IRL that kind of personality would be way too much to deal with.
ReplyDeleteAllie of
www.allienyc.com
Romance novels are not typically my favorite genre, as I prefer to read books that are centered around adventure and suspense. Misunderstandings are used too often— they simply become annoying and tiresome.
ReplyDelete